February 9, 2004

Not just blog, reBlog

Jonah Peretti has cooked up a really interesting new way to blog at E Y E B E A M's reBlog. With the help of some friends he created a hack that takes entries from feed on feeds and publishes them to a movabletype blog.

The point of the hack is obvious - this is a way of filtering, or better yet, editing RSS feeds. So instead of taking anything and everything that comes through the feed, they've created a system that allows them some editorial control over it.

My only criticism in this experiment is that it is a one-way proposition. They have not enabled comments nor trackbacks. I can understand wanting to do away with comments but with the trackbacks? Blogs are not just publishing tools, they are also social software.

Shouldn't blogs be somewhat open to the society of strangers that might pass through them instead of pass them by?

Posted by liza at February 9, 2004 12:21 AM

Liza: What an interesting idea! One can achieve the same result using a JournURL community and its integrated aggregator, but the thought simply never occurred to me.

re: disabled Trackbacks

I suppose it makes sense if you want to avoid taking the focus away from the source blogs.

Hm... perhaps that could be addressed with a "passthrough ping"? The reblog entry accepts a ping, but rather than (or in addition to) directly incorporating it, the reblog forwards the ping on to the source. Could be really cool, although I suppose there's a real potential for abuse.

Posted by: Roger Benningfield at February 9, 2004 2:25 PM

it would be a whole lot easier to understand if i actually understood what an RSS is and how all this works. but hey, that's just me.

Posted by: alyssa at February 9, 2004 9:37 PM

it would be a whole lot easier to understand if i actually understood what an RSS is and how all this works. but hey, that's just me.

Posted by: alyssa at February 10, 2004 7:26 AM

What is RSS? It's a format used to make a subscribable list of recent updates or items from a news or blog feed. The name is a red herring. Roger Benningfield is going to start calling it Subscribe or "the subscribe button" or something like that.

To paraphrase the white knight from Alice Through the Looking Glass:

RSS is RDF Site Summary
RSS is called Rich Site Summary
RSS's name is Really Simple Syndication
RSS's name is called RSS


I'm going to post this over on Pirillo's Lockergnome RSS site....

Posted by: xian at February 10, 2004 11:14 AM

I just wish I could get the code from someone to accomplish this very thing... I have feed on feeds AND MovableType, and I need to accomplish this same task, which is super cool that someone has done it, the only question is (after visiting their site, too) HOW!!!!??????!!!

Posted by: BrotherPhil at February 18, 2004 11:48 AM
Other incoming links (via Technorati)

Hosted by Mediajunkie.

Sponsors
On this day in 2005
Easy as 1-2-3 ... 49-50-51: How To Start Your Very Own Blog In Fifty-One Easy Steps! (kuro5hin.org)... (Miscellany)
On this day in 2003
Blather beats pr0n again: Hey, I just passed Pornographer's Picks to regain the coveted No. 8 spot in Salon's all-time blog rankings. Woo-hoo. We're No. 8! We're No. 8! USA! USA!... (Salon Bloggers)
FIONA on Radio Userland: A picture ~= 1 kiloword, right? I've had that feeling too, at times. Anyway, Fiona is my new favorite cartoonist. When will we be seeing her work in the New Yorker (or in Salon proper, for that matter)?... (Salon Bloggers)
Shirky on blogging and inequality: Internet pundit Clay Shirky writes about power-law distributions and the popularity of certain blogs. He disputes the idea that there's a specific "A-List" but says that unequal distribution of readership is inevitable. Mark Pilgrim mostly agrees. Dave Winer mostly disagrees and thinks that Clay needs to start a blog himself to... (Weblog Concepts)